In a thought-provoking talk, Smita Mukerji takes the audience on a comprehensive exploration of the historical role of the military. The talk, scheduled on Martyr’s Day, delves into specific criticisms related to Subhas Chandra Bose and examines the military’s approach to Islam.

Mukerji begins by distinguishing between true martyrs, those who defend the nation with their lives, and individuals like Gandhi, whom she perceives as victims of their own deeds. She then delves into the overarching theme of the military as historical instruments, portraying soldiers as pawns whose lives have been sacrificed for various individuals, ideals, identities, or interests. The speaker addresses key issues, starting with the discrediting of Subhas Chandra Bose, focusing on criticisms related to the operative language of the Indian National Army. Mukerji also challenges perceptions about the military’s approach to Islam, referring to Mukerji questions the alleged lack of clarity among military men in dealing with Islam and challenges the skepticism about the military’s efforts in areas like Kashmir and the Northeast. She explores whether the military is expected to deal with Islamic ideology and critiques claims of delusional secularism among Indian military personnel. a recent Sangam Talks video featuring Major-General G. D. Bakshi and Major Gaurav Arya.

Emphasizing that the military is an arm of the state, Mukerji highlights the importance of its lack of reliance on ideology. She argues for a professional and ideology-free stance, warning against using ideology as a basis for military action due to its potential for inconsistency, unreliability, and internal conflicts.