UGC 2026: कहानी दो आयोगों के अध्यक्षों की; जाति, आरक्षण पर इतना भ्रम क्यों? | प्रशान्त पाण्डेय

Is reservation worse than the very evil it set out to eliminate? Kaka Kalelkar said exactly this — in his own report.
This video by Sangam Talks presents a deep analysis of India’s two historic Backward Classes Commissions — the Kaka Kalelkar Commission (1953) and the Mandal Commission (1979). The video reveals how Kalelkar himself was unable to step outside the framework of caste, even though he knew that the real causes of backwardness are many. It examines, layer by layer, the Mandal Commission’s recommendation of 27% reservation, the constitutional obligations under Articles 15(4) and 16(4), and how the color of caste politics shifted after VP Singh implemented it.
The most important argument made is that British rule deliberately pushed Indian society into a “Battle of Survival,” destroying industry and education — and that even 75 years after independence, caste remains the cheapest, most elegant, and most durable political tool of that same policy. The video concludes with a sharp question — do we truly want to break this spell of caste?

वक्ता परिचय:
प्रशान्त पाण्डेय वर्तमान में सेन्टर फॉर हिन्दू आइडेंटिटी स्टडीज़ (सीएचआईएस) के निदेशक हैं । वे लगभग दो दशकों तक पत्रकार रहे, और कई राष्ट्रीय अंग्रेज़ी समाचार-पत्रों के लिए कार्य किया । वे पुस्तक प्रकाशन से भी जुड़े रहे । इन्होंने दो पुस्तकें, जिनमें से एक है BBC’s True Lies, का सह-लेखन भी किया है ।

Leave a Reply