What really happened when Marxist historians tried to erase the Ram Temple evidence at Ayodhya? Journalist Arvind Singh delivers the forensic answer.
In his book The Rogue Historian, Singh traces how JNU-affiliated historians — orchestrated behind the scenes by Irfan Habib — entered the Ram Janmabhoomi debate in 1986, declaring Ram’s birthplace a myth, and then used every institutional lever available to deny the Hindu claim. Drawing on court records, ASI trench notebooks, GPR survey reports, and cross-examination transcripts, he documents how they sabotaged Chandrasekhar-era peace talks, opposed the court-ordered excavation, and even attempted to cap the dig depth to protect what lay beneath.
When the ASI unearthed 50 pillar bases, a pranala, and architectural features unmistakably belonging to North Indian temples, the historians pivoted through a sequence of counter-theories — a Kanati mosque, a Buddhist stupa, then a Jain structure — before each collapsed in court. Key figures admitted they had never descended into the trenches they testified about, had publicly denied evidence they had never examined, and confessed their statements were, by their own word, propaganda. The Supreme Court’s 2019 judgment awarded the site to Hindus. Singh calls for a two-to-three generational effort to undo the lasting damage to India’s historical consciousness.
About The Speakers:
Arvind Singh is a journalist with over three decades of experience. Before India’s Rogue Historians, he authored Once Upon a Crime, based on real-life events, which received much acclaim. He has also edited several books and is working on a new book on the 1948 Brahmin genocide.
Debasis Sarkar is an Anchor at Sangam Talks. He is an independent researcher in Indology and a seeker in related fields of knowledge.