In a thought-provoking YouTube video, Dr. Koenraad Elst delves into the contentious issue surrounding the alleged Brahminical persecution against Buddhism. The talk aims to address contemporary claims circulating on social media, challenging the narrative that Hindu rulers orchestrated the destruction of Buddhist monasteries. Dr. Elst begins by dispelling the notion that the Buddha himself faced persecution by Hindus. Contrary to the fate of other religious founders like Jesus and Muhammad, the Buddha did not meet a violent end orchestrated by Hindus.

Dr. Elst clarifies that attempts on the Buddha’s life were instigated by a jealous pupil within his own order, lacking any ideological motivation. The discussion delves into historical accounts, focusing on the figure of Pushyamitra. Dr. Elst scrutinizes the Divya Vadana’s claim that Pushyamitra promised rewards for bringing in the severed heads of Buddhist monks, highlighting challenges associated with such accounts, including the lack of eyewitness evidence and ideological considerations. Drawing parallels with an account involving Ashoka, where rewards were offered for heads of people from rival sects, Dr. Elst challenges the perception of Ashoka as a purely peaceful figure associated with Buddhism.

The overarching theme of the talk revolves around challenging the narrative of a Brahminical “jihad” against Buddhism. Dr. Elst encourages a nuanced understanding of historical events, cautioning against simplistic and one-sided interpretations. The discussion prompts viewers to critically evaluate evidence and consider the broader context in which these historical events unfolded.